Pines Liquor Shop
Adjacent to the Pantry, the Pines Liquor Shop offers an extensive range of wine, spirits, craft cocktails, and mixers. Whether preparing for an evening out or hosting at home, this convenient shop ensures every occasion is well supplied.
The Visitors Center
A recent addition to the harbor, the Visitors Center showcases a selection of locally designed merchandise, queer-made goods, and seasonal treats, including soft-serve ice cream. It is both a welcoming resource for newcomers and a stylish stop for longtime residents.
TOLA. Boutique
TOLA is an elegant boutique situated near the harbor, offering a carefully curated collection of gifts, fine jewelry, candles, and coastal-inspired apparel. It’s the perfect destination for a refined accessory before dinner or a distinctive keepsake that captures the spirit of the Pines.
The Pines Pantry
As the primary market in the community, the Pines Pantry provides a thoughtfully stocked selection of fresh produce, gourmet snacks, sandwiches, and everyday necessities. Guests and residents alike know it best for its signature homemade chocolate chip cookies — a beloved local indulgence not to be missed.
Camp (Flowers & Hardware)
Camp combines the unexpected charm of a floral studio with the practicality of a hardware store. From fresh bouquets to household essentials, it has become a delightful stop that balances utility with beauty — a true hallmark of life in the Pines.
Restaurants in Fire Island Pines
Pines Pizza
For relaxed dining in the heart of the harbor, Pines Pizza is always a favorite. Generous slices, crisp salads, and a lively deck create an atmosphere perfect for unwinding with friends. It strikes the ideal balance of ease and quality, offering the kind of casual meal that still feels distinctly part of the Pines experience
Canteen
Perfectly positioned by the ferry dock, Canteen is a reliable stop for classic favorites at any hour of the day. From breakfast sandwiches before the beach to quick bites between events, and late-night fries after dancing, it provides unfussy comfort with consistent quality. Its simplicity is part of its enduring appeal.
Pines Bistro & Martini Bar
The Bistro sets the standard for refined dining in the community. With both indoor and outdoor seating, it offers a warm and inviting setting complemented by its signature martinis. The menu features a well-rounded selection designed to please a variety of tastes, making it a preferred choice for elegant dinners during the summer season and a reliable gathering spot year-round.
Blue Whale (Marina Bar + Grill)
The Blue Whale is a true Pines landmark, seamlessly blending casual elegance with vibrant energy. Overlooking the harbor, it is the place where brunch lingers into cocktails and cocktails naturally lead to the renowned Low Tea. Sunset views are unmatched, while evening piano nights add a touch of timeless charm. Whether for a leisurely meal or an evening gathering, the Blue Whale is a destination guests return to again and again.
Nightlife in Fire Island Pines
The Pool Deck at The Tryst
Poised to become a daytime destination, the Pool Deck at The Tryst will offer an ideal blend of leisure and entertainment. With cocktails by the water, live DJ sets, and a vibrant social scene, it promises to be one of the premier spots for enjoying the Pines’ energy under the sun.a
Pavilion
The Pavilion is the centerpiece of Pines nightlife — an iconic open-air dance floor that draws world-class DJs and an electric crowd well into the night. Known for its energy and atmosphere, it is the definitive experience of Fire Island Pines, and no stay is complete without stepping onto its floor at least once.
Sip N Twirl
Equally beloved yet more relaxed in tone, Sip N Twirl offers a lively setting to begin the evening. Guests gather over the bar’s signature frozen Punch cocktails before transitioning seamlessly to the dance floor as the night unfolds. It is a quintessential stop, balancing social connection with the spirited character of the Pines.
Restaurants in Cherry Grove
Cherry Grove Pizza
Cherry Grove Pizza serves oversized New York–style pies and hearty pasta dishes in a casual setting. Ideal for a quick slice between beach outings or a relaxed dinner with friends.
Floyd’s
The only breakfast option open before 10 AM in Cherry Grove, Floyd’s is a cozy, local favorite known for coffee and classic morning fare. Reservations are recommended during the busy summer season.
Sweet Licks
Sweet Licks is the community ice cream shop, offering a variety of classic and seasonal flavors. A staple for cooling off on warm afternoons by the beach.
Island Breeze
Island Breeze features outdoor seating on a deck overlooking the Great South Bay. The menu includes casual staples and fresh seafood, making it a popular choice for a relaxed midday meal with a waterfront view.
Top of the Bay
Top of the Bay combines elevated versions of familiar dishes with sweeping sunset views across the bay. A premier dinner destination, especially in peak season when reservations are essential.
The Sandcastle
One of only two true beachfront restaurants on Fire Island, The Sandcastle has been a local fixture since the 1950s. Guests enjoy uninterrupted ocean views paired with cocktails and fresh seafood, making it a quintessential destination for waterfront dining.
Cherry’s on the Bay
Cherry’s on the Bay combines casual dining with lively waterfront views. Located beside the ferry dock, it offers a menu of approachable favorites alongside cocktails best enjoyed outdoors. Throughout the season, the venue is also known for its near-daily drag shows and performances, adding entertainment to the dining experience and making it one of Cherry Grove’s most vibrant destinations.
Nightlife & Entertainment in Cherry Grove
Ice Palace
The Ice Palace is a landmark nightlife destination in Cherry Grove, recognized for its vibrant energy and longstanding legacy. Throughout the summer, it hosts drag shows, dance parties, and themed events, making it the community’s most iconic venue for evening entertainment.
Cherry’s on the Bay
Cherry’s on the Bay is a lively waterfront bar situated beside the ferry dock, offering sweeping views of the bay and a front-row seat to departing and arriving ferries. The venue is also a hub of entertainment, with drag shows and performances presented nearly every day throughout the season, making it one of Cherry Grove’s most dynamic gathering spots.
Shopping in Cherry Grove
Coastal Roots
The Plant Nursery in Cherry Grove carries a rotating selection of trees, shrubs, perennials, and ornamental grasses, along with professional-grade potting soil, compost, and fertilizers. On weekends, fresh-cut flower bouquets are also available, offering a simple way to add color and charm to any Fire Island home.
The FIG Store & General Store
The FIG Store offers Fire Island–themed apparel and souvenirs, while the nearby general store by the Ice Palace provides a wide selection of beach essentials and novelty items. Together, they give visitors convenient options for both keepsakes and everyday necessities.
Barrier Beach
Barrier Beach is a boutique gift shop featuring Fire Island–inspired clothing and accessories. Its selection of apparel and keepsakes makes it a go-to for visitors looking to take home something stylish and distinctly local.
Jalston
Galston offers a refined selection of upscale clothing, with a focus on elevated styles and quality craftsmanship. It stands out as one of Cherry Grove’s more sophisticated shopping destinations.
Rainbow Dreams
Rainbow Dreams is an eclectic boutique with a wide-ranging selection that includes clothing, jewelry, accessories, and novelty items. Part fun drag shop and part treasure trove, it’s known for its bold, colorful pieces and statement-making finds.