Fire Island Homes for Sale

$1,825,000

This Horace Gifford Home has been completely renovated and remodeled. Professionally decorated and immaculately cared for. It doesn’t get better than this! Treat yourself to this luxury vacation home and you will be back season after season. Listing courtesy VP Real Estate

$1,950,000

Exclusive Listing ( Sold On August 1, 2026 ) JOHN FORTE ASSOCIATE BROKER Welcome to A true masterpiece of modern coastal living. This Chic and Stylish 3 bedroom 3.5 bathroom Bayfront property offers every amenity to complement a luxurious lifestyle. Every detail has been thoughtfully curat [...]

$1,350,000

Quaint and comfortable 3 bedroom with pool. Newly renovated bathroom, updated kitchen and stylish decor make this rental perfect for your beach get-a-way.

$1,425,000

597 Cottage Walk is a welcoming retreat tucked into a private enclave of just 3 properties, The open living / dining room & kitchen spills out onto the large pool deck set amid a captivating garden. 3 thoughtfully appointed bedrooms & 3 full baths. Additional amenities include air conditioning [...]

$1,599,000

Welcome to 267 Bay Walk, where entertaining and comfort meet! Nestled in the heart of Fire Island Pines just steps from the beach. Step inside to discover a meticulously renovated, stylish sanctuary, where every detail has been carefully curated for your enjoyment. Sun-drenched and spacious, [...]

$1,150,000

All new...multilevel decking provides great entertaining space. Ocean views. Very private pool. Two bedrooms are cabana style – great for guests!

On the west side of Fire Island Pines sits a unique residence that  stands as a a testament to architectural brilliance, envisioned by the renowned architect James Mcleod.The home seamlessly integrates luxury with functionality. The design showcases Mcleod's style, marrying contemporary aesth [...]

$1,100,000

Ocean Front Co-op Easy Co-op Living. Stunning new renovation. Professionally decorated two bedroom oceanfront co-op with custom features and every amenity. Attention to every detail and designed for enjoyment. High ceilings and exposed beams are consistent with the island atmosphere [...]

This one bedroom co-op is complete with updated appliances, air conditioning and renovated bathroom. Easy living in the co-ops only steps to the ocean. In the co-ops, you are close to everything!