Fire Island Homes for Sale

$1,950,000

Exclusive Listing ( Sold On August 1, 2026 ) JOHN FORTE ASSOCIATE BROKER Welcome to A true masterpiece of modern coastal living. This Chic and Stylish 3 bedroom 3.5 bathroom Bayfront property offers every amenity to complement a luxurious lifestyle. Every detail has been thoughtfully curat [...]

$1,350,000

Quaint and comfortable 3 bedroom with pool. Newly renovated bathroom, updated kitchen and stylish decor make this rental perfect for your beach get-a-way.

$1,425,000

597 Cottage Walk is a welcoming retreat tucked into a private enclave of just 3 properties, The open living / dining room & kitchen spills out onto the large pool deck set amid a captivating garden. 3 thoughtfully appointed bedrooms & 3 full baths. Additional amenities include air conditioning [...]

$1,599,000

Welcome to 267 Bay Walk, where entertaining and comfort meet! Nestled in the heart of Fire Island Pines just steps from the beach. Step inside to discover a meticulously renovated, stylish sanctuary, where every detail has been carefully curated for your enjoyment. Sun-drenched and spacious, [...]

$1,150,000

All new...multilevel decking provides great entertaining space. Ocean views. Very private pool. Two bedrooms are cabana style – great for guests!

On the west side of Fire Island Pines sits a unique residence that  stands as a a testament to architectural brilliance, envisioned by the renowned architect James Mcleod.The home seamlessly integrates luxury with functionality. The design showcases Mcleod's style, marrying contemporary aesth [...]

$1,100,000

Ocean Front Co-op Easy Co-op Living. Stunning new renovation. Professionally decorated two bedroom oceanfront co-op with custom features and every amenity. Attention to every detail and designed for enjoyment. High ceilings and exposed beams are consistent with the island atmosphere [...]

This one bedroom co-op is complete with updated appliances, air conditioning and renovated bathroom. Easy living in the co-ops only steps to the ocean. In the co-ops, you are close to everything!

$650,000

Newly on the market! Beautifully decorated two bedroom Co-op. Enjoy the ease and comfort of being in the center of town and steps to the ocean. Large exterior space and ocean views….this unit has it all!