Results

$1,400,000

A truly unparalleled investment opportunity on Fire Island--an iconic two-story, Bayfront commercial property located right at the Cherry Grove ferry dock. Spanning over 2,400 square feet, this rare gem offers a prime location, high visibility, and versatile income potential. The ground flo [...]

$1,950,000

New Exclusive Listing A true Fire Island Pines classic designed by iconic architect Horace Gifford. 487 Tarpon Walk is a sleek, modern 3 bed, 2 bath retreat featuring his signature clean lines, open living spaces, and seamless indoor-outdoor flow. Surrounded by lush landscaping with a p [...]

Charming 1-bedroom beach cottage located in the heart of Cherry Grove, just steps from the newly restored beach. This cozy retreat features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning for warm summer days, and a private outdoor shower. Enjoy laid-back outdoor living with a BBQ grill and a peace [...]

Welcome to this Lovely Private gardens retreat on the West end of Cherry Grove! Pets are welcome. Please contact our office today for availability and more info. 631-597-7000

$375,000

This rarely available corner one-bedroom unit has come on to the market. This is the most sought after floor plan in the co-ops. Large corner sunny terrace. Chefs kitchen, Washer .Dryer. Steps to Ocean and close to town. Enjoy carefree living at the Fire Island Pines Co-ops.

Welcome to the Cherry Grove Manor! This well-maintained and newly renovated studio offers Bayview, access to the community pool and is available for weekly rentals in 2025.

Secluded escape in beautiful Fire Island Pines! 3br/2ba classic Pines bungalow with a huge deck and large pool overlooking acres of unspoiled natural beauty. Total privacy; your next door neighbor is protected National Seashore! 90 second walk to ocean access and located mid-way between Che [...]

$120,000

Located on the coveted west end of Cherry Grove, this stunning corner property is one of the largest and most impressive homes in the community. With two spacious bedrooms and two full bathrooms, this bayfront masterpiece offers expansive water views, ultimate privacy, and effortless indoor-ou [...]

$125,000

This iconic 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath Gifford-designed home is tucked away at the end of Shore Walk, offering rare privacy and timeless mid-century style. Enjoy a full summer season in the Pines with standout amenities including a sun-drenched pool, spacious deck, and a private hot tub surrounded by [...]