Cherry Grove Vacation Rentals

Available for rent for the 2025 season: A sunlit unit situated within the Star Building. This unit boasts a downstairs one-bedroom complemented by a fully-furnished office space on the upper level, ideally tailored to accommodate a remote worker.

Enjoy the amazing sunsets in this wonderful 3 bed 2 bath home on the bay while sipping your cocktail in the oversized heated pool. Or just relax on the large deck that extends all the way to the bay!!

$56,000

This quaint 2 bedroom 1 bath cottage has been completely renovated. All new kitchen, bath, vaulted ceilings, gas fireplace, A/C & heat. All new decking, brand new pool and outdoor shower. Very close to town!!

Newly renovated and ready to welcome you to the Fire Island Experience. Large sun drenched exterior living space. Solar Heated Pool. Fully Air Conditioned. Open floor plan with high ceilings. Finely appointed with every amenity. Conveniently located and priced right! Hurry, your perfect vac [...]

$10,000

Welcome to Cloud 8 - A Coastal Retreat in Fire Island Pines. Tucked away on a serene corner lot in the west end of Fire Island Pines . Cloud 8 will be your dream escape. This lovely 3-bedroom ,3 bath home is the epitome of light and bright living, with walls of glass that invite the outd [...]

Check out this classic Fire Island Pines gem located on Ocean Walk. This 4 bedroom 4 bathroom house is a 2 minute walk from the Harbor! Each bedroom has its own en-suite bathroom for privacy and convenience. Enjoy your time on the expansive second story deck where you can enjoy views of the At [...]

Priced right for your perfect Fire Island Vacation. Grab your besties and head to this ideal share house! 4 equal bedrooms with Tv and New A/C and 2 shared baths. Secluded backyard oasis with a Salt water, solar heated pool and just close enough to town and the beach to be considered the pe [...]

Wednesday at 2pm to Tuesday 6pm Schedule Private, steps from the ocean Modern, up-to-date, renovation. 346 Sunburst Walk was completely renovated in 2019-2020 with new siding, decking, swimming pool, A/C and new spacious bedrooms and bathrooms. This home also features a new kitchen, new [...]

$12,500

This pristine 3 Bedroom plus den home is perfect for your vacation rental. Large outdoor entertaining space complete with heated pool and hot tub.