Cherry Grove Seasonal Rentals

$17,000

Great “beachy” beach house with a terrific location and huge pool with full sun. Very private gardens, large screened in porch, hammock, wi-fi, satellite TV, phone, outdoor shower. Very Private Lot!

$1,679,000.00

New Exclusive Listing Welcome to 267 Bay Walk, where entertaining and comfort meet! Nestled in the heart of Fire Island Pines just steps from the beach. Step inside to discover a meticulously renovated, stylish sanctuary, where every detail has been carefully curated for your enjoyment. Su [...]

$1,399,900

Great share house. Poolside bedrooms stay cool while you get the views from the great room and roof deck. 3 bedrooms with 2 twin bed 1 bed with 2 Full beds

$1,795,000

On the west side of Fire Island Pines sits a unique residence that  stands as a a testament to architectural brilliance, envisioned by the renowned architect James Mcleod.The home seamlessly integrates luxury with functionality. The design showcases Mcleod's style, marrying contemporary aesth [...]

$1,200,000

This ranch style home is perfect for entertaining, for renting, or for some good ol' privacy. Set back from the Boulevard and nestled on the west end - retreat to your own piece of Fire Island Pines paradise. Updated kitchen with granite counter tops, hardwood floors throughout, Bedrooms [...]

Amazing ocean views from every room with a large master suite! Quaint living space opens up to a gorgeous wrap around deck. This is a MUST SEE!

This 3 bedroom beach house is all about charm. Great location close to town. Enjoy the hot tub on this specious deck with lots of sun. Open kitchen great for entertaining, fire place, outdoor shower. The perfect beach get away.

This newly renovated Co-Op is situated on the first floor just off Harbor Walk. This home boasts a brand new kitchen with stainless steel appliances and an open layout. 1 bedroom that is configured with a King bed and walk in closet with laundry. 2024 Rental Availability: 6 Week Minimum